On Day 3, Matt is reluctant to speak about his wife's disappearance to the press, who are beginning to gain the upper hand on the police with their own probes. Meanwhile, Hazel worries that Kyle may be involved in the case.

On Day 33, Matt takes the kids to a carnival as a distraction from their grief, but a gruesome discovery in a lake opens a new chapter in the investigation. Meanwhile, Tanya begs her father to take her back to France with him, and John and Barbara grow more concerned about Ethan and Rosie's welfare.