Serena wants Boyce and Hart to play at the Cosmos Cotillion, but they are booked "until 1976". Serena puts a spell on them to make them unpopular until they perform at the cotillion and sing her song. Once they perform at the Cotillion, Samantha insists Serena remove the spell.

At the office, Darrin meets Dusty, daughter of important client John Harrison who clearly only wants to learn the business. Because she promised to not interfere, Endora enlists Serena's help in casting a spell that makes Dusty fall madly in love with Darrin.