After Vicky is arrested for erasing a videotape that the Turners were saving so then they could use it to get their own reality show, she is forced to take over Dimmsdale and wage war on Earth. Timmy must now stop her and return her to babysitting at all costs. Unfortunately, every time Timmy wishes she was not the ruler of something, she once again becomes a ruler of an extremely powerful position (Mayor of Dimmsdale, President, finally Supreme Ruler of Everything That Breathes) and destroys the world anyway. In order to stop her, Timmy must boldly wish she was his baby-sitter again.

Timmy tries to find a safer job for Catman (a.k.a. Adam West) after constant injury, but each job leads to someone/something getting attacked.