When Timmy's parents discover Cosmo, Wanda, and Poof, Timmy must prevent Jorgen from finding out about it, or else he will lose his fairies forever.

Timmy Turner makes his millionth wish, which all of Fairy World has gathered to celebrate, but after reviewing his wishes, the Fairy Council finds that Timmy should be put on trial for being the "worst godchild ever." Wanda, Cosmo, and Poof try to prove that Timmy is not, until the truth comes out that Timmy has made a secret wish that no one can know about, not even his godfamily.

Timmy Turner's enemies collaborate to form the League of Super Evil Revenge Seekers (L.O.S.E.R.S.) in order to annihilate him at the same time. When a rare astronomical event known as the Fairy-clipse does not allow Cosmo, Wanda, Poof (and also Foop) to use their magic to save him, Timmy is capable of outwitting the L.O.S.E.R.S. by himself.

In a trip to Hawaii, Timmy wishes his parents were the best surfers on the beach in order to impress a pretty hula girl, but that wish starts a wish limbo, in which they will not stop fighting until only one of them prevails as the best surfer.

Timmy has Cosmo, Wanda, and Poof pose as ghosts so that his parents can re-live their glory days as ghost hunters.

Centuries ago, the Anti-Fairies and Fairies started an annual bake-off to determine which species gets godchildren. This year, Jorgen's recipe is at risk, and Anti-Cosmo and Anti-Wanda are determined to make sure they make Timmy their godchild by stealing the recipe and cheating the fairies out of the competition. Timmy now has to get the recipe back so the Anti-Fairies' scheme will backfire and he will remain Cosmo and Wanda's godchild.

When Mr. Turner reveals he dropped off school at 5th grade, he attempts to graduate from Dimmsdale Elementary School in order to make his son proud.

After Dad gets lost while looking for their hotel and lands on a deserted island, he struggles to make a boat to save his family to prove his masculinity and does not let anyone help him. Meanwhile, Poof finds a nuclear bomb in the sand and Cosmo activates it, putting the Turners' life at risk unless Timmy can defuse it.

After Timmy tells Poof a scary story, the baby's crying keeps him up all night, so Timmy wishes for no light for twelve hours of the day. However, Timmy does not know that when his godparents are kept in the dark for longer than eight hours, they become "Boogie Godparents" and turn on their godchild.

Doug Dimmadome selects the Turners to go on a space mission, but it turns out he was really Dark Laser in disguise, with an elaborate plan to take revenge on Timmy and trap the Turners in a space zoo on his Death Ball. In this episode, Timmy's parents are revealed to be more intelligent than before, because they (smartly) say the opposite of what they want so Dark Laser will do "terrible things" (opposite of what they want) to them.

After Timmy almost had to eat Mom's stinky food, Timmy wishes his mom was the best cook on Earth, but when she enters a cooking competition, the magic wears off and she has to face the challenge alone.

After mysterious appearances of monsters in Dimmsdale, Crocker starts a webshow to comment on it, and asks for viewers to call if they see a monster.

Frustrated with his job because he keeps getting stuck in traffic, Mr. Turner quits and tries to start up a farm instead. Unfortunately, despite believing he has a green thumb, he has no luck at growing anything, so Timmy wishes his father's crops would grow huge. Now, however, Timmy's father has so much success that he wants his family to stay on the farm forever. Things get even harder when the fairies are swept away by a tornado and end up in Cleveland, which means Timmy has to do much of the work alone.

When Jorgen gets the trickups (hiccups that cause stage magician-like trick magic) he is unable to enforce Da Rules, so he must pass it on to his closest relative until he gets better. Unfortunately, his closest relative is Cosmo, his long-lost cousin, and chaos instantly ensues.

Timmy borrows Mark Chang's "iFake" disguising device in order to attend Trixie's costume party. Unfortunately for him, his lack of knowledge about Yugopotamian technology puts him in a tight spot when he accidentally puts the device in shuffle mode, turning him into different monsters.

The Dads that Timmy wished up kidnap his Mom and Timmy has to rescue her.

Mr. Turner becomes obsessed with proving Dinkleberg is evil, and drags Timmy into a 24/7 spying mission, leaving Timmy unable to contact his fairies or ask for wishes.

With Poof's first day in spellementary school, he and Foop compete to be the most popular student there, but Foop takes it to extremes when it becomes clear that his classmates favour his fairy counterpart more than him.

Poof and Foop compete with each other for the lead role in a Spellementary School play alongside with a triangle shaped female fairy baby named Goldie Goldenglow.