PJ is unwillingly drawn into a dinner date with a geeky former classmate, but events turn worse when he fails to call her back. Elsewhere, a reorganization in the Cubs front office could spell the end of Mike's job; and Brendan's broken romance causes him to swear off alcohol.

A past kiss between PJ and Brendan continues to stir up tension. Elsewhere, Kenny scores a new girlfriend, and Andy acclimates himself to suburbia and its tiresome commute.