PJ and Co. take Andy to the friendly confines of Wrigley Field as his wife prepares a party for him at the gang's hangout. Meanwhile, PJ and Brendan's romantic history is exposed; and Kenny is haunted by a figure from his past.

PJ is called on to be a guest on a local-cable sports show. In other events, Stephanie tries to persuade PJ to go on a sojourn to Italy, and Andy grapples with his long commute to and from suburbia.