Teddy asks Spencer to the school dance, and they double with Ivy and Emmett. The boys wind up in a "dance-off" but end up bonding, leading Teddy to feel Emmett has "stolen" her date.

In order to get Amy to let her go to a midnight movie, Teddy pretends her mom is cool. The plan works until Teddy butt-dials Amy from her new phone, leaving Amy to overhear that Teddy was just pretending to have fun.