When Doris Lovett, a mother from a small town, is abducted in the middle of the day from outside her home, Jack realizes that the case bears an uncomfortable similarity to a serial killer case he dealt with 12 years ago.

When an unknown Hispanic boy is abducted in plain sight from a Spanish Harlem street, Jack and the team are perplexed as to why nobody comes forward to report him missing. During the course of the investigation, Martin is pushed to breaking point, compromising both Vivian and himself.