The team searches for a teenage figure skater who disappears after practice one day and discover that many people in her life had reason to worry. The team's investigation leads to the rink's operator, a convicted rapist who was the last to see the girl.

Jack finds himself in the hotseat when Emily Grant, a young white woman and Darnell Williams, a young black man, go missing on the same night and Jack is ordered to put more of the team's resources into finding the young woman.