Mike Williams vanishes while duck hunting on a Florida lake, in an apparent accident. Nancy Grace traces how the victim's mother launched a campaign to learn the truth that uncovered a tale of greed, betrayal, murder, and injustice.

Michelle Mockbee is beaten to death at the Kentucky warehouse where she works, and cops realize the killer is likely a co-worker. They must eliminate employees one-by-one until the suspect is finally revealed, along with an outrageous motive.