When Pamela Vitale is found brutally murdered in her home on a California mountainside, detectives are led down a dark path to a killer hiding in plain sight. But even a sentence of life without parole can't guarantee this killer won't walk free.

When Utah teen Annie Kasprzak is brutally murdered, one solid lead after another evaporates in a haze of rumors and lies. After a suspect is finally in custody, Annie's family fights to make sure this killer's sentencing is just.