As Zach and Tori prepare to welcome a new member to the family, they receive some concerning news from their realtor; after another disagreement with Amy over the farm, Matt makes a proposal to separate the two properties.

With their home still unsold, and bills mounting, Zach struggles to come up with the perfect low-cost anniversary surprise for Tori; when the guys crash the ladies' beach trip, Amy and Chris butt heads; tempers flare between Matt and Amy.