John Haplin and the Stivilletos demand their own brand of justice; Andrew considers running away with Georgia; Carol transforms herself.

Merritt and Henley come up with a plan to take back the mysterious hammer in Peggy's possession; Tommy thinks he smells a rat; landlady Dot Meadows regrets filing a police report after finding dead birds in the woods.

The interrogation of John Haplin about missing Lauryn Ward intensifies; Tommy views the future of his relationship with Big Dave anxiously after having a nightmare; Merritt and Peggy form an unlikely bond.

Rachel wants to leave Haplin; a long-kept secret is revealed; Andrew and Georgia's day in the woods takes a shocking turn.

Clues point to the return of the elusive Magic Man; Tommy finds an unlikely ally while searching for his wife; gruesome evidence could be good news for many of Haplin's families.

A state investigator steps in to assist Tommy on Friddle's murder. Andrew exacts revenge on the person he believes assaulted his girlfriend Georgia. A handsome stranger rescues Henley from a bizarre car accident.

Newly appointed Sheriff Tommy Conroy makes a shocking discovery about Jerry Friddle's murderer; Henley is determined to access the third floor of the mysterious boarding house.

Henley Boone moves to a seemingly idyllic town just as a shocking murder occurs; Tommy, a deputy and son of a popular sheriff, tries to ease the town's fears and solve the crime.