The season wraps up with Aubrey asking Nick to choose between her and Hannah; Ray telling Owen about Ikey and Alison; and Physical Phil trying to get Pizza Girl back.

Nick and Hannah wait for Sam to come out of surgery; Physical Phil attempts to get even with two frat guys who accosted Pizza Girl. Meanwhile, Eddie and Ikey deal separately with their secret relationships.

Nick and Ronnie suspect the Commander is dating; Physical Phil has dinner with the pizza-delivery gal; and Eddie finds out that Big Cat is looking to get revenge on their group of friends.

Nick tries to help Sam woo his crush by using the three-point plan described in his novel. Meanwhile, Eddie and Janet begin secretly dating, and Physical Phil works up the courage to "ask in" the pizza-delivery gal.

Nick decides to stay in Knights Ridge and tries to persuade the local college's hard-nosed dean to give him a job. Meanwhile, the Commander investigates whether Sam is actually his grandson, and Eddie sees a chance to hurt Nick by seducing Nick's new friend Aubrey.

Popular author Nick Garrett returns to his hometown to beat writer's block and learns he might have a child with his ex-girlfriend Hannah.