Investigators find a 14-year-old pitcher dead, and the discovery shocks residents in Davis, California, as a baseball rivalry suddenly emerges as possible motive. 

When a teenager disappears in North Carolina, her group of friends and their usual hangout spot become the focus of the investigation into her disappearance. As their stories begin to change, suspicion grows and the truth about that night slowly comes into question.  

Investigators find a young woman murdered in a California apartment, throwing a tight-knit theater group into chaos. As they search for answers, suspicion spreads through the case, leaving friends to question who they can trust.  

When an 18-year-old computer whiz vanishes after leaving a friend's house in rural Georgia, his close friend group bonds together to search for answers. As days pass with no sign of him, suspicion grows and detectives begin to question th9ose closest to him. 

When an Auburn University graduate disappears, her tight-knit group of friends falls under suspicion. As investigators chase leads and rumors spread, distrust grows until new evidence reveals a chilling truth about someone close to her. 

In the season premiere, after a woman disappears in Florida, her friends uncover a hidden life filled with new relationships and secrets. As investigators follow the trail, suspicion shifts toward someone in her inner circle who may know more than they've revealed.