Both Lucifer and Marcus try to get together with Chloe, while Maze is furious that Marcus has called off their deal to frame Lucifer for Marcus' murder. Meanwhile, the partners investigate the death of a ballerina who was strangled with a slipper tie.

After Chloe breaks up with Marcus, Lucifer tries to recreate what it was like when he and Chloe first met. Meanwhile, Charlotte realizes that the suspect in a woman's death may be tied to a duffel bag she was asked to dispose of 13 years ago.