Amy amps up the store's Halloween spirit to impress the new district manager— even setting up a haunted house that Glenn is terrified to enter. Jonah collects the last of the union cards, while Cheyenne and Mateo wonder if any of the Cloud 9 employees are capable of murder.

Amy and Jonah help Mateo run a toy drive to make him look good for his immigration hearing, but they clash with a competing charity rep. Sandra and Jerry ask Glenn to officiate their wedding despite Dina's protests. Cheyenne gets real with Garrett about his relationship with Colleen.