After throwing his back out playing with his daughter, Jack vows to get in shape and hires a personal trainer who used to be a Navy SEAL. Nina can't figure out why she's not attracted to the trainer, despite his good looks and his obvious interest in her. Maya enlists Finch's help to co-write a screenplay about a vampire cop.

Finch is frustrated when an old nemesis shows up to gloat over his success. Not only does he own a successful business, he is also engaged to their high school homecoming queen. Desperate to impress his old nemesis, Finch plans to wed an insecure supermodel.