In need of an apartment, Finch convinces Maya and Elliott to move in together, with disastrous results. Jack and Nina both try to avoid their annual anniversary night out.

Finch's old skating partner returns, and asks him to coach her and her new partner. Just before the skating competition, she twists her ankle, forcing Finch to take her place. Maya has dyed her hair blonde. Nina is thrilled that her A&E biography is airing, but when Ed McMahon is struck by a bus, she fears that his death will lead to the cancellation of her program.