Angie is haunted by stories of Russell's ex-girlfriends, so she attempts to transform the house from a bachelor pad to a married home. Meanwhile, Tracy tries to get her daughter to embrace their shared Filipino culture.

Mitch and Tracy are excited to welcome a new couple, Steve and Stephen, to the neighborhood, but it quickly goes south when their barking dog keeps Sadie up all night. Mitch is left with the dilemma of either confronting his new neighbors or charming his way into their hearts. Meanwhile, Russell is determined to convince Angie that they should get a dog of their own, and he's willing to do anything to show he's ready for the responsibility.