Pastor William B. Guthrie is charged with the murder of his wife, Sharon; while one of the pastor's daughters believes it was suicide, the other is convinced it was murder, and the sisters reconnect after years of silence to finally face the truth.

The case of a small-town New Jersey police chief who was accused of trying to arrange the murder of his estranged wife is seen through the eyes of his sister, whose faith in his innocence has been shaken.