Paul is responsible for picking up Jonathan's son for a playdate, but the task doesn't go as planned. Elsewhere, Paul tries to make peace with an intimidating man (Henry Rollins) who feels Paul has wronged him.

TV star Paul Reiser auditions for a game show produced by Mark Burnett and learns he's competing with Larry David for the job in the premiere of this comedy series. Meanwhile, Paul's pals go overboard while helping their kids with school projects.