Kevin & Tabatha Bryant are a picture-perfect couple, living with their two young sons in Penfield, New York. But when Tabatha is found stabbed to death at home, a steamy affair and many double lives are revealed to the town's unsuspecting residents.

William Walker is a prominent firefighter, living in a tight-knit Cleveland neighborhood with his new wife, Uloma. But the couple's world is shattered when William is gunned down in their driveway, causing everyone in his life to be a prime suspect.