Washington Redskins safety Sean Taylor is killed during a home invasion, leading many to wonder if it was a crazed fan, a targeted hit, or an inside job. But after media speculation runs wild, an anonymous tip reveals the shocking truth. 

When Cincinnati Reds player Dernell Stenson goes missing during the Arizona Fall League, teammates demand answers. An investigation turns up a shocking murder, and the possibility of a killer hunting professional baseball players.

In the competitive landscape of Dallas High School basketball, a rising star, Troy Causey, is murdered under suspicious circumstances. Homicide detectives unearth hard evidence of a shocking conspiracy that ripples throughout the school district. 

When former NBA Memphis Grizzly player Lorenzen Wright is found murdered, whispers of unpaid debts and cartel connections lead many to question how well they knew their hometown hero. But a mother's fight for justice reveals a truth more shocking than the rumors.

When St. Louis Blues player Mike Danton is arrested immediately following the Stanley Cup Playoffs, it sends shockwaves through the hockey world. Could an NHL player be involved in a murder for hire plot?  

Baylor University basketball player Patrick Dennehy, who went missing in 2003. For the first time ever, his teammate Ellis Kidd, Jr. shares his personal account of the murder investigation that led to exposing one of college basketball's biggest scandals.