The premiere season explores high-profile cases including: the tragic home invasion of NFL star Sean Taylor, featuring commentary from former Washington Redskins teammate Santana Moss; the robbery-turned-murder of MLB player Dernell Stenson, with insights from his friend and former teammate Mike Gallo; the arrest of NHL player Mike Danton in a murder-for-hire plot, with an interview from former professional hockey player and teammate Joe Goodenow; and more, with each case revealing how the pursuit of greatness can collide with tragedy in ways that continue to reverberate years later.